Benelli vs. Beretta: Which Shotgun is Best for Duck Hunting?

In this post, we will be comparing two popular shotguns in the waterfowl hunting world: Benelli and Beretta. Both brands offer high-quality firearms that are used by hunters and shooters worldwide. However, when it comes to duck hunting, which one of these shotguns is better? Let's dive deep into each platform to uncover the good, the bad, and the ugly.

Product Overview

Before we get into the review itself, let's quickly go over each shotgun's key features:

Benelli Super Black Eagle III:

• Inertia-Driven System for reliable cycling
• ComfortTech 3 recoil reduction system
• AirTouch Grip checkering for a secure hold
• Crio System barrel and choke tubes for improved shot patterns
• Available in different camo patterns

Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus:

• Blink gas-operated system for fast cycling
• Kick-Off Mega recoil reduction system
• Aqua Technology for increased corrosion resistance
• Optima Bore HP choke system for improved shot patterns
• Available in different camo patterns

Who We Are

As avid duck hunters, we've had the opportunity to use both the Benelli Super Black Eagle III and the Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus in the field. While we aren't professional gun reviewers, we've put both guns through their paces and want to share our thoughts on each.

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

Now, let's break down each feature one by one and see how the two shotguns compare:

Reliability: Both Benelli and Beretta are known for their reliability, but the Super Black Eagle III's Inertia-Driven System gives it the edge in this category. The system uses the energy from the recoil to cycle the next shell, resulting in a reliable and fast cycling firearm.

Recoil Reduction: Both shotguns have advanced recoil reduction systems. The Benelli ComfortTech 3 and Beretta Kick-Off Mega systems are both highly effective in reducing felt recoil, but the ComfortTech 3 is slightly more comfortable and doesn't add as much weight to the gun.

Shot Patterns: The Crio System on the Benelli and the Optima Bore HP system on the Beretta both provide excellent shot patterns. However, the Benelli's Crio System produces slightly tighter patterns and is more consistent across different loads.

Weight and Balance: Both shotguns are lightweight and well-balanced, making them easy to carry and shoulder for extended periods. However, the Benelli's AirTouch Grip checkering gives it a more secure hold, especially in wet and slippery conditions.

Water Resistance: Beretta's Aqua Technology provides increased corrosion resistance to the A400 Xtreme Plus, making it the clear winner in this category. However, both shotguns have good water-resistant features.

Overall, both shotguns are excellent choices for duck hunting, and the choice ultimately comes down to personal preference. The Benelli Super Black Eagle III is more reliable and has a slightly better shot pattern, while the Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus has better recoil reduction and water resistance features.

Product Showdown Conclusion

If you're in the market for a new duck hunting shotgun, either the Benelli Super Black Eagle III or the Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus would be a great choice. Both shotguns offer advanced features and high-quality construction. Ultimately, the choice is yours, and we encourage you to try both shotguns out for yourself before making a final decision.